The decision was taken at a meeting of telecom operators and the General Prosecutor’s Office of the State Agency of Communications, where she discussed the implementation of the decision of the court on blocking films “innocent Muslims” and “I’m gay, I’m a Muslim.”
Today, October 2, 2012, at the State Communications Agency hosted a meeting of the General Prosecutor’s Office of Kyrgyzstan and operators to discuss the decision of the Court of Bishkek Pervomaisky about blocking films “innocent Muslims” and “I’m gay, I am a Muslim” in the country. The meeting was also attended by representatives of the National Security Committee of the Kyrgyz Republic, the CEO of KR, the Director and staff of the Public Foundation “Civil Initiative on Internet Policy.” The main item on the agenda was to ensure enforcement of the judgment by the telecom operators.
Representatives of telecom operators and CEO expressed concern that the court’s decision can not be implemented fully and without reservation, since these films are not tied to a particular resource, and can be copied and replicated in the space of the Internet on any resource and any user. The court’s decision is not given to methodology for ensuring lock.
Bring you the abridged transcript of the discussion:
IT-specialist company SkyMobile (brand «Beeline»): to ensure the non-proliferation of this movie, they need to constantly monitor the network and its share on the presence of this film as well as the rest of the Internet space, which will lead to a huge labor costs in , but nevertheless do not provide 100% of the result.
Lawyer SkyMobile (brand «Beeline»): the task of operators is only providing data services and they are not related to the content. We specifically obtain a license to do so and legally registered our duty free and full access to the Internet users. You need to decide who will execute the decision, operators or Internet resources. Please suggest your vision to ensure that decision (subject to PGO).
Tattu Mambetalieva, director of PF CIIP: let us recall the situation with the film “Hour of the Jackal.” Then, with our technical advice, we recommend you to send a request services such as YouTube and Yandex on blocking of the film. And because they reacted. Besides, you do not want to block the first time resources to court. Let’s you do something in the legal field will all be addressed.
Bit-Ibrahim, General Prosecutor’s Office representative, when these films come out, we have to respond within our mandate, given the situation in our country and in the world. We send those requests to the state agencies that are responsible for the link, in this case, agency communications, and they should be blocked. We are not asking you to lock resources, we ask you to limit access to the film. I understand that it is technically difficult, but it should work.
IT-specialist company “Aknet”: We provide transportation only content, but the content, we do not have a relationship. It’s like that in order to stop the transportation of drugs to close all roads and borders. You see, we are just “pipe” to deliver the product. A monitor content, it is not in the first place would cost one million U.S. dollars, and secondly it is censorship and interference in the personal lives of its customers, the violation of the Constitution and the correspondence and negotiations. So you want to, let’s say that we watched you swing on the internet or whatever you have in your mail?
Bit-Ibrahim, General Prosecutor’s Office representative, let us decide what to do then. Co …
Tattu Mambetalieva, director of PF CIIP: write requests resources and Yandex YouTube or Google them to block the host this movie. Actually, let’s give up the practice of blocking content, it is a bad precedent.
The representative of the CEO, Tatiana Klochkova: Let us then offer operators to control their communication server and the specific resources. We need to develop a methodology for blocking.
Deputy Director of the CEO, Genghis Bektashev: let so. We are all witnesses to what happened in other countries because of the movie. And we need to take some measures. I agree that you need to write to the Google and other resources about blocking this movie in Kyrgyzstan on behalf Ministretstva Transport and the Ministry of Foreign Affairs. It somehow will solve the problem. This is the first step. Second, service providers, I understand your concern, but please make an effort to control your server for this film and try to prevent its spread.
The representative of “Aknet”: how to control our servers? There are many different files, including video. And if the user renames or even encrypt. How can we be? We agree to respond, but only on request and remove the film from their networks during the day.
Following the meeting, it was decided to send a letter to Google as the owner of the resource to the YouTube and other major video servers to block this film for Kyrgyz citizens, service providers to control their own server for this film, and deleted at the request of the film during the day.
Prepared by Erkin Mamasaliev
Translated by Google Translate
The International consortium for the Development of Digital Legislation has successfully completed work on the draft Digital Code for Kyrgyzstan, this document will create a favorable regulatory
On the International Children's Day on June 1, the Children's Information Technology Forum "Kids IT Day" was held in Kyrgyzstan for the first time.
The children's forum was organized for children
On December 14, 2018, Public Foundation Civic Initiative of Internet Policy held a training course on the issues of forensics (computer forensics), digital evidence fixing, cybercrime investigations.
